Tithe.ly asked for my password and PIN, but I never created an account.

We recommend that each donor create an account upon their first donation. Creating an account allows you to see your donation history, change a payment method, and change recurring giving.
If you did not create an account, tithe.ly automatically created one for you based on your e-mail. For security, you will need to reset your password and pin to access your account. To do this, please click “Reset Password”. Tithe.ly will have you enter the e-mail address you used for your previous donation and send you an e-mail with a link to reset your password. Navigate back to the portal on our website. Enter your e-mail address and password. When it asks for your PIN, please click “Forgot your PIN?”. Tithe.ly will again send you an e-mail with instructions on resetting your PIN.
Navigate back to the portal on our website. Enter your login credentials and your PIN.